MailVitals vs Valimail: Complete Monitoring vs DMARC-Only Enforcement
Valimail focuses exclusively on DMARC enforcement at $5,000+/year. MailVitals Beat gives you comprehensive email health monitoring from $27/mo: blacklists, content analysis and DMARC, with inbox placement from $57/mo.
Pricing
Beat's plan prices next to Valimail's published pricing.
| Feature | MailVitals | Valimail |
|---|---|---|
| 1 domain | $27/mo (Minimum) | $5,000+/yr |
| Up to 10 domains | $57/mo ($570/yr billed annually) | $5,000+/yr |
| Up to 50 domains | $97/mo ($970/yr billed annually) | Custom |
Features
Here's how MailVitals and Valimail compare feature-by-feature.
| Feature | MailVitals | Valimail |
|---|---|---|
| DMARC Monitoring & Reports | Yes | Yes |
| DMARC Enforcement Automation | No | Yes |
| Blacklist Monitoring | Yes | No |
| Inbox Placement Testing | Yes | No |
| Email Content Checker | Yes | No |
| 70+ Data Point Email Test | Yes | No |
| MX Record Monitoring | Yes | No |
| Domain Health Dashboard | Yes | No |
| Free Tools (no signup) | Yes | Free Monitor only |
| SMB-Friendly Pricing | Yes | No |
The verdict
Valimail is the gold standard for enterprise DMARC enforcement, but its $5,000+/year price tag puts it out of reach for SMBs, agencies, and cold email operators. More importantly, Valimail only does DMARC. There is no blacklist monitoring, no inbox placement testing, and no email content analysis. MailVitals Beat delivers comprehensive email health monitoring from $27/month, with Strong at $970/year (billed annually) for up to 50 domains.
Competitor pricing and features as published by Valimail. Verify before purchase. Vendors change plans without notice.
Other comparisons
A heartbeat for your email.
Beat runs every check on this site on a schedule: 41 checks, 50 blacklists and real inbox placement. The moment something breaks, it tells you what broke, why it matters, and the exact fix.
- SPFpass
- DKIMpass
- DMARCp=none
- Blacklists0 / 50
Illustrative. Your domain, every few hours.
Also from us:Pulse: your own sending infrastructureConsulting: $65/hr, no retainer